Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me - 1992 - NA
Two fanedits that extend FWWM as much as possible.
Straight off, I am absolutely NOT the Lynch guy.
After the mess of S02, Twin Peaks, the show was canceled, and Fire Walk With Me was judged incomprehensible.
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me: Teresa Banks and the Last Seven Days of Laura Palmer - Q2
Q2 refashioned FWWM with deleted scenes, outtakes, to better follow Lynch’s vision. Maybe. With Lynch, one never knows.
Some of the material was never remastered, so one cannot judge against video defects.
Sound design in FWWM is dazzling. From tiny sounds to noise to the hypnotic roadhouse band.
Regarding the narrative, I am convinced there is a tight story in here, but an extended version just pumps more fog into the confusion.
FBI subplots seem meaningless to the plot. Just Lynch ridiculing them.
The extended narrative wanders aimlessly for over an hour, then it locks in and grows inspired. The sound mix, the brooding tone, the fatalistic dread. A one-way Noir ticket to Hell.
By the end of the film, there was more here I liked than disliked. I will also be the first to admit hard core Twin Peaks fans will revel in this extended edition.
* *
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me: Extended Blue Rose - igorleoni
This is the second edit I have watched, which attempts to reinsert missing footage into Lynch’s “feature”.
With this director, I am never sure of anything. I find him more maddening than Herzog.
Anyway, the first section of this plays out like amateur, community theatre. I don’t know if these performers cannot act, or of they have been directed to emulate drunken cacti.
Once Laura Palmer appears, the acting turns professional, although the story continues to meander somewhat. Just hold on and bear with it.
The truckstop sequence is unforgettable.
The image quality if this is excellent, the audio adequate. Subtitles are unnecessary.
I still suffer enjoyment / appreciate issues with this film. Indeed with this director’s oeuvre, or the director himself, whom I’ve always equated with the unclothed emperor.
In many ways, this is similar to Q2’s version, and my comments from 2014 mirror my thoughts toward this edit.
For
Twin Peaks fans, and Lynch believers, both versions are strongly recommended.